Mindful Clicking: How To Foster A Culture Of Cybersecurity In Schools

Emails are an undeniable constant in the rhythm of a busy school day, delivering everything from urgent updates and communications from government departments to sensitive student information. For educators and staff, quickly clicking through emails can often feel like just another task on an ever-growing to-do list. However, as phishing attacks become increasingly sophisticated and more frequent, the way you handle emails should become a critical component of school cybersecurity.

This is precisely where school leaders and governors play a crucial role. Cultivating a culture where mindful email practices are not only encouraged but ingrained isn't merely about protecting sensitive data; it's about empowering every member of staff to feel personally invested in the collective safety and security of the entire school community.

So, how can you, as a member of the senior leadership team (SLT) or governance, help build this essential culture and ensure email interactions are a safer, more thoughtful process for everyone? In this blog post, we'll share practical tips to foster 'mindful clicking' within your organisation, enhancing your school's resilience against cyber threats.

Lead by example

Leadership teams are pivotal in establishing the cybersecurity culture across the entire school. A powerful starting point for this is becoming a role model for other staff members. When staff observe SLT members demonstrating care with emails by verifying senders, pausing before clicking, and thinking critically, they’re far more likely to adopt similar habits themselves. 

Additionally, SLT members should be transparent about their own email practices. This includes scheduling dedicated time in their diaries for reviewing emails, proactively flagging suspicious content, and avoiding rushed decisions during periods of high cognitive demand.

Actively modelling these behaviours sends an unequivocal message: mindful email practice isn't merely a recommendation; it's a fundamental best practice for every individual in a school community, from teaching assistants to headteachers.

Integrate mindful email practices into the daily routine

One of the most impactful actions SLTs can take is to integrate mindful email practices into the fabric of the school day. This could involve designating specific, brief windows (perhaps after core school hours or during quieter periods) where staff are encouraged to focus exclusively on essential emails with undivided attention. 

Rather than relegating email management to rushed breaks or the gaps between meetings, providing staff with dedicated time for this task significantly reduces the pressure to multitask and directly enhances decision-making quality. By embedding mindful email engagement as a standard routine, schools can demonstrably reduce errors stemming from cognitive overload (Rizzoni, 2022), thereby bolstering overall cybersecurity.

Encourage a healthy email culture

It's widely acknowledged that the sheer volume of emails within a school environment can be overwhelming. School leaders can be uniquely positioned to address this by proactively shaping the school's email culture. This means fostering an environment where it's acceptable to pause and not respond instantly, and where emails aren't used for self-protection or to assign blame.

Governors, in particular, can play a crucial role by establishing clear guidelines around email communication. These guidelines should emphasise that not every email requires an immediate response and should actively discourage after-hours email demands. This collective effort promotes a more thoughtful, cautious approach to email handling, which directly reduces the likelihood of rushed, thoughtless clicks on malicious links and strengthens your school's cybersecurity posture.

Recue email overload: Send smarter, not more

One of the most straightforward ways to improve your school's cybersecurity posture is by reducing the overall volume of emails. Fewer emails inherently mean fewer opportunities for phishing attempts to slip through unnoticed. 

Here's how you and your colleagues can adopt more thoughtful email sending habits:

1️⃣ Avoid 'Send All' and 'Reply All' unless essential

Mass emails contribute significantly to inbox clutter, making it harder for staff to identify genuinely important or potentially suspicious messages. Use mass emails sparingly, and always ask yourself: "Does everyone on this list truly need this information, or need to see my reply?"

2️⃣ Limit access to mailing lists

For widely distributed group email addresses, such as allstaff@yourschool, restrict who has permission to send messages to them. This simple measure drastically reduces irrelevant traffic.

3️⃣ Consolidate messages

Instead of sending multiple short emails throughout the day, aim to consolidate your thoughts into one clear message. Fewer emails lead to a less chaotic inbox and enable recipients to process information more efficiently. While consolidating, strive to keep each email focused on a single topic rather than bundling multiple unrelated points. This enhances clarity and allows recipients to address each point effectively. For numerous points or complex details, consider whether a brief meeting or a direct conversation might be more effective. A discussion often allows for clearer understanding, faster clarification, and more immediate feedback than a lengthy email chain.

By practicing these more thoughtful habits in sending and responding to emails, you can significantly reduce the sheer volume of messages in your inboxes. This makes it considerably easier to spot sophisticated phishing attempts and ensures staff can focus on the communications that truly require their attention.

Provide regular reminders and gentle nudges

Consistent reminders from leadership are vital for maintaining mindful email habits across the school. Whether delivered during a staff meeting, through a quick update in daily briefings, or via internal communications, encouraging staff to slow down and "think before you click" helps keep cybersecurity awareness at the forefront without resorting to overly formal or heavy-handed training.

Crucially, governors and SLT members must actively reinforce that staff will not be penalised for taking their time with emails. Instead, encourage staff to flag emails for later review if they feel rushed, overwhelmed, or cognitively fatigued. This approach promotes the fundamental principle that careful, considered review is always superior to quick, reactive responses (Greitzer, 2021), directly reducing the risk of accidental clicks on malicious links.

Create a non-judgmental reporting environment 

Mistakes are an inevitable part of human activity. Even the most vigilant staff member might, at some point, inadvertently click on something suspicious. It's therefore critical for SLT and governance to cultivate an environment where staff feel entirely comfortable reporting potential mistakes without fear of embarrassment or consequences.

When staff know they can report suspected phishing attempts (or accidental clicks) without judgment, they're far more likely to take immediate action. This rapid reporting significantly speeds up the response time for IT teams, enabling them to mitigate potential damage far more effectively. Furthermore, it actively reinforces a vital culture of openness and transparency within the school community. By consistently framing these incidents as valuable learning opportunities, SLT can profoundly help staff feel more involved and personally invested in robust cybersecurity practices.

Run phishing simulations with positive reinforcement 

Phishing simulations are powerful tools for building cybersecurity awareness, but they must be handled carefully. School leadership and governance can ensure these exercises are supportive rather than punitive.

Instead of solely focusing on identifying mistakes, leadership should reward positive behaviors, such as successfully identifying and reporting phishing attempts. This type of positive reinforcement cultivates a more engaged, proactive cybersecurity culture. When staff know their vigilance and effort are recognised, they're far more likely to approach email management with the necessary care, rather than acting out of fear of making a mistake.

Make cybersecurity everyone's responsibility

Governance teams can profoundly emphasise that cybersecurity isn't solely an IT concern; it's a shared responsibility involving every individual within the school. Cultivating a culture of involvement means actively empowering every staff member to feel personally accountable for protecting school data.

Regular communication from both leadership and governors about how each person’s actions contribute to the overall security posture of the entire school can have a significant impact. When staff genuinely feel that their individual choices, such as taking a moment to carefully check an email, directly help strengthen the school’s digital defences, they are far more likely to take these seemingly small, yet crucial, steps seriously.

Final thoughts: A culture of careful clicking

Amidst the constant demands of school life, it's easy to view emails as simply another task to complete. However, by actively encouraging mindful email habits, leaders and governors can make a significant difference in reducing phishing risks and fundamentally strengthening the cybersecurity culture across the entire school community.

Building this crucial culture doesn't demand sweeping, disruptive changes. Instead, it's about implementing subtle yet impactful adjustments that empower everyone to slow down, pay closer attention, and feel genuinely involved in their school's security.

From scheduling dedicated email time to implementing supportive phishing simulations and fostering a non-judgmental reporting environment, leadership and governance are uniquely positioned to lead the way. By championing a culture of careful clicking and mindful decisions, you can significantly enhance your school's resilience against evolving cyber threats.

Enjoyed this blog?

Well, this has actually been available on our Community for a while. As a member, you can access more exclusive content from our experts, attend webinars, and even speak directly with hundreds of like-minded people in schools. 

Sign up for free here.